Download source: ftp://206.165.251.49/h umongous/PuttZooDemo.sit.bin
 

Rating: (1-5)

Relevance to objectives: (5) The game is full of problems and puzzles that aren't to difficult to solve for the all the age groups.  My son is 4 and my daughter is 7.  The both find the game fun and their ages still leave room for exploration methods within the game. The game continously interesting and still meets and exceeds the objectives.
Provides practice of relevant skills:  (5) Always allows for practice of both computer and problem solving skills.  The children are always involved in a puzzle that Putt-Putt assists the child with through hints if they can't figure it out on their own.  My son has some difficulty solving all the problems but as time goes on Putt-Putt prompts him to the solution through hints.
Likely to arouse/maintain interest: (5) The game has real advantages for given the age group of the programs intended audience.  My little boy and girl loves the game.  On a rainy or cold day they request Putt-Putt.
Likely to be comprehended clearly: (5) The puzzles vary in difficulty but Putt-Putt is always there to assist.  The children laugh and are excited when they solve the problem.  A reward is usually there for them when they solve the puzzle singing dancing animals etc.
Technical quality (durable, attractive): (5) The game uses Putt-Putt's dashboard as the interface between the children. It is simple and well presented; my four year-old was using the game in no time. We leave the two of them alone and the only time they need us is when they want to show us some of the excellent animation after they solve a problem.
Game: Winning dependent on player actions (rather than chance): (5)  The kids have a goal to win by finding all the babies.  Hidden within these goals are the problem solving objectives of the game.  With Putt-Putt's assistance winning the game is easy for all age groups.
Simulation: Validity of game model (realistic, accurate depiction): (5) The game is full of  detailed fun. Almost every object you double click on provides entertainment and amusement for the children.  Within the game itself are all kinds hidden mysteries and games to play as well. The animals talk and sing, ice move on the pond the mother animals try to help the children.  The games audio visual effects are great.  The game is well done professionally. 
Evidence of effectiveness (e.g. field-test results): (5) My children both love the game my 4 year old is challenged much more than my seven year old.  My seven year old still enjoys the game but the challenges are not difficult.
Clear directions for play:   The game is driven through the dash board and the mouse.  The game gives motivation through interaction with Putt-Putt.  The game provides directions and hints to the child when having difficulty.
Effectiveness of debriefing: (5) I'm not an expert but for the price and the evidence my children have produced I recommend this game for kids from 3-7.  The game is well worth it as a father and for my children.